Reasoning
PIQA Leaderboard
PIQA (Physical Interaction QA) asks a model to choose the more sensible of two ways to accomplish an everyday physical task, testing practical, physical-world commonsense that isn't well captured by purely textual reasoning tests.
Source: epoch40 open models ranked+19 proprietaryData through Dec 2024
Open models ranked on PIQA
# shows rank among open models / rank overall (including proprietary).
| # | Model | Score | VRAM @ Q4 |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 / 2 | Phi 3.5 MoE Instruct · 41.9B | 88.6% | ~26 GB |
| 2 / 4 | Llama 3.1 405B · 405.9B | 85.9% | ~268 GB |
| 3 / 5 | Falcon 180B · 180B | 84.9% | ~396 GB |
| 4 / 8 | DeepSeek v2 · 235.7B | 83.9% | ~144 GB |
| 5 / 9 | Gemma 2 9B · 9.2B | 83.7% | ~6.1 GB |
| 6 / 10 | Mixtral 8x7B v0.1 · 46.7B | 83.6% | ~29 GB |
| 7 / 11 | Mistral Nemo Base 2407 · 12.2B | 83.5% | ~8.1 GB |
| 8 / 12 | StableBeluga2 · 70B | 83.3% | ~43 GB |
| 9 / 14 | Falcon 40B · 41.8B | 83.0% | ~28 GB |
| 10 / 15 | Mistral 7B v0.1 · 7.2B | 83.0% | ~4.9 GB |
| 11 / 16 | Llama 2 70B HF · 69.0B | 82.8% | ~152 GB |
| 12 / 18 | Qwen2.5 72B · 72.7B | 82.6% | ~45 GB |
| 13 / 23 | Mistral 7B Instruct v0.1 · 7.2B | 82.2% | ~4.9 GB |
| 14 / 24 | Mistral 7B Instruct v0.2 · 7.2B | 82.2% | ~4.9 GB |
| 15 / 29 | Gemma 7B · 8.5B | 81.2% | ~19 GB |
| 16 / 30 | Llama 3.1 8B Instruct · 8.0B | 81.2% | ~5.3 GB |
| 17 / 31 | Phi 3.5 Mini Instruct · 3.8B | 81.0% | ~3.4 GB |
| 18 / 32 | Llama 2 13B HF · 13.0B | 80.8% | ~8.6 GB |
| 19 / 35 | Falcon 7B · 7.2B | 80.3% | ~4.8 GB |
| 20 / 36 | Internlm 20B · 20B | 80.3% | ~43 GB |
| 21 / 38 | Qwen 14B · 14.2B | 79.9% | ~9.3 GB |
| 22 / 39 | Llama 7B · 6.7B | 79.8% | ~4.5 GB |
| 23 / 40 | Llama 2 7B HF · 6.7B | 78.8% | ~4.5 GB |
| 24 / 41 | Baichuan2 13B Base · 13B | 78.1% | ~8.6 GB |
| 25 / 42 | Internlm 7B · 7B | 77.9% | ~15 GB |
| 26 / 43 | Qwen 7B · 7.7B | 77.9% | ~5.1 GB |
| 27 / 45 | Gemma 2B · 2.5B | 77.3% | ~1.6 GB |
| 28 / 46 | RedPajama INCITE 7B Base · 7B | 76.9% | ~4.6 GB |
| 29 / 47 | GPT Neox 20B · 20.7B | 76.7% | ~14 GB |
| 30 / 48 | Baichuan 7B · 7B | 76.2% | ~4.6 GB |
| 31 / 49 | Open Llama 7B · 7B | 76.0% | ~4.6 GB |
| 32 / 50 | Opt 1.3B · 1.3B | 75.7% | ~2.9 GB |
| 33 / 51 | Xgen 7B 8k Base · 7B | 75.5% | ~4.6 GB |
| 34 / 53 | GPT J 6B · 6B | 75.4% | ~4.0 GB |
| 35 / 54 | Cerebras GPT 13B · 13B | 73.5% | ~29 GB |
| 36 / 55 | Qwen 1 8B · 1.8B | 73.3% | ~1.2 GB |
| 37 / 56 | GPT Neo 2.7B · 2.7B | 72.9% | ~6.0 GB |
| 38 / 57 | Gpt2 Xl · 1.6B | 70.5% | ~1.1 GB |
| 39 / 58 | Chatglm2 6B · 6B | 69.6% | ~4.0 GB |
| 40 / 59 | Stablelm Tuned Alpha 7B · 7B | 65.8% | ~4.6 GB |
Score vs model size
Which models give the most quality for their size — the ones worth running locally.
- Opt 1.3B, 1B, score 75.7% — on the efficiency frontier (best score at its size or smaller).
- Gemma 2B, 3B, score 77.3% — on the efficiency frontier (best score at its size or smaller).
- Phi 3.5 Mini Instruct, 4B, score 81.0% — on the efficiency frontier (best score at its size or smaller).
- Mistral 7B v0.1, 7B, score 83.0% — on the efficiency frontier (best score at its size or smaller).
- Gemma 2 9B, 9B, score 83.7% — on the efficiency frontier (best score at its size or smaller).
- Phi 3.5 MoE Instruct, 42B, score 88.6% — on the efficiency frontier (best score at its size or smaller).
PIQA: frequently asked questions
- What is the best open LLM on PIQA?
- Phi 3.5 MoE Instruct is the top open model on PIQA, scoring 88.6%. Among all models tested — including proprietary ones — it ranks #2. The top model overall is GPT 4o Mini (Jul 18, 2024) (OpenAI) at 88.7%.
- What's the best PIQA model you can run on a 24 GB GPU?
- Gemma 2 9B is the highest-scoring open model that fits in 24 GB at 4-bit quantization (~6.1 GB), scoring 83.7% on PIQA.
- What's the best PIQA model you can run on a 12 GB GPU?
- Gemma 2 9B is the highest-scoring open model that fits in 12 GB at 4-bit quantization (~6.1 GB), scoring 83.7% on PIQA.
- Can open models match proprietary models on PIQA?
- Not quite on PIQA: the strongest proprietary model (GPT 4o Mini (Jul 18, 2024)) scores 88.7%, ahead of the best open model (Phi 3.5 MoE Instruct) at 88.6% — but you can run the open one yourself.
Scores aggregated from epoch. llmrun does not run this benchmark — see the source for methodology, or the about benchmarks for what it measures.